The Panel: Does Inoue need to fight in the US to be a bona fide star?

Gary Lockett (Trainer)

In my opinion, I believe there is some truth in both perspectives. While I agree with Shawn Porter to some degree, I firmly believe that Naoya Inoue has already established himself as a genuine star and ranks among the top three pound-for-pound fighters. However, I do comprehend Porter’s viewpoint that the most significant fights have historically taken place in Las Vegas or Madison Square Garden. These locations offer a larger and more diverse audience, and I do believe that Inoue has the potential to become a superstar if he were to compete in America.

Gary Logan (Trainer)

Shawn Porter seems to believe that without an American audience, one cannot attract much attention in the boxing world, whether it be in the States or Saudi Arabia. He claims that Devin Haney lacks recognition among many Americans due to his limited exposure on a significant platform. According to him, even a less active Tyson Fury garners more recognition in the United States than Haney. However, I respectfully disagree with Porter’s perspective on this matter.

Jamie Conlan (Promoter)

I strongly disagree with that statement. In my opinion, Naoya Inoue is undeniably a global superstar. He has elevated the status of smaller weight classes and inspired others to do the same. While I understand Shawn Porter’s perspective, it seems that America often believes it is the center of the universe. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that this is not the case, as evidenced by the international recognition and support Inoue receives. Therefore, it is evident that Inoue does not necessarily need to compete in America to solidify his status.

Andy Lee (Trainer)

Inoue aspires to achieve greatness and he has indeed accomplished it. He shines as a prominent figure and enjoys immense popularity in Japan. While it was once believed that breaking into the American market was crucial, the boxing industry has evolved into a truly global phenomenon. The most anticipated matches no longer exclusively take place in America; instead, they are held in various locations including Saudi Arabia and other countries. Therefore, I respectfully disagree with Porter’s viewpoint.