Mets vs Yankees MLB Subway Series Picks & Best Bets (7/23)

Today’s Mets vs. Yankees MLB predictions and best bets are brought to you by BetOnline. BetOnline is a market leader in sports betting, offering various options from MLB Subway Series odds to the NBA and everything in between.

The second half of the 2024 MLB Subway Series begins on Tuesday when the New York Mets (51-48) take on the New York Yankees (60-42) in a 7:05 p.m. ET showdown at Yankee Stadium.

Tonight’s rivalry matchup between the Mets and Yankees is not only exciting due to the history between the franchises but also presents several MLB betting opportunities. In this article, we will explore some standout predictions and best bets for this game.

2024 MLB Betting Picks Record: 56-66-1 (45.9%)

MLB Betting Today: Mets vs Yankees (7/23)

Mets vs Yankees Subway Series Information

Matchup: New York Mets (51-48, 25-22 Away) vs. New York Yankees (60-42, 27-21 Home)
Venue & Location: Yankee Stadium (Bronx, NY)
Date: Tuesday, July 23, 2024
Game Time: 7:05 p.m. ET
How to Watch Mets vs. Yankees: MLB.TV, Fubo, TBS

Mets vs Yankees MLB Probable Pitchers

Mets: Jose Quintana (19 starts — 4-6, 4.13 ERA)
Yankees: Luis Gil (19 starts — 10-5, 3.17 ERA)

Yankees vs Mets MLB Odds & Spread

Yankees vs. Mets MLB odds are courtesy of BetOnline as of Tuesday, July 23 at 10:57 a.m. ET. Odds from other top online sportsbooks may also be mentioned in this article.

Mets vs Yankees Run Line

New York Mets +1.5 (-149)
New York Yankees -1.5 (+129)

Yankees vs Mets Over/Under

Over 9 Runs (-115)
Under 9 Runs (-105)

Mets vs Yankees Moneyline

New York Mets (+143)
New York Yankees (-156)

How to Bet on 2024 MLB Season

Hoping to get in on the 2024 World Series betting action? Want to wager on more than just the Mets vs. Yankees Subway Series? Betting News has your baseball needs covered from March to November.

Below, you will find a variety of baseball betting resources to assist you in getting started. These include daily MLB odds, betting predictions, and expert picks.

MLB Betting Articles
MLB Betting Odds
MLB Picks Page

Mets vs Yankees MLB Betting Trends

In their previous nine games against the AL East, the Mets have a record of 2 wins and 7 losses.
In their past 15 home games, the Yankees have a record of 4 wins and 11 losses.
In five of the Mets’ last seven games, the total exceeded the Over.
In four out of the Yankees’ last six games against the NL East, the total surpassed the Over mark.
In four out of the last six Mets-Yankees matchups, the total score exceeded expectations.

Mets vs Yankees Predictions & MLB Picks Today (7/23)

As the 2024 Subway Series enters its second half, both of New York’s MLB teams are feeling the increasing pressure. The Mets are determined to maintain their hold on the NL’s final wild-card spot, with seven teams hot on their heels within a 4.5 game range. On the other hand, the Yankees currently hold the top spot among AL’s wild-card clubs, but their position is not guaranteed unless they maintain a consistent winning streak.

The Yankees don’t gain much advantage by playing at home either. Despite having a record of 27-21 at Yankee Stadium this season, they have only managed to win four out of their last 15 home games since mid-June. However, this might not be significant considering the Mets have only won four out of their previous 10 away games.

It will be intriguing to observe if the Mets can continue their momentum from the first half of the Subway Series. Their consecutive victories over the Yankees last month, with a remarkable aggregate score of 21-9 in their favor, showcased their potential. However, the Yankees have struggled in the subsequent 20 games, recording a 8-12 win-loss record, while the Mets have fared better with a 12-9 win-loss record during that period.

Do the Mets have what it takes to take a 3-0 season series lead over the Yankees tonight?

After securing victories last month, the Mets have achieved an 11-6 SU record in their previous 17 encounters with the Yankees. However, their triumphs do not extend to the Bronx. In their last nine visits to Yankee Stadium, the Mets have suffered six losses, with four of them resulting in multiple-run deficits.

The odds of achieving victory will increase if Mets LHP Jose Quintana can bounce back. Despite recent signs of improvement, the experienced left-handed pitcher regressed to his previous form in a disappointing performance against the Colorado Rockies last week. Allowing five earned runs and four home runs on six hits across 5 2/3 innings, the team suffered an 8-5 loss. Additionally, Quintana has only managed to win one of his last six appearances against the Yankees.

When it comes to the home team, it will be intriguing to see how Luis Gil performs tonight. The right-handed pitcher for the Yankees had a rough time towards the end of June but has managed to regain his form, only giving up two earned runs and striking out 16 batters in his last 12 2/3 innings. Additionally, he will be eager to redeem himself after allowing five earned runs in 4 1/3 innings against the Mets last month.

Which version of Yankees RHP Luis Gil will appear on the mound tonight?

After being swept at Citi Field last month, look for the Yankees to win tonight. The Bronx Bombers have momentum stemming from yesterday’s 9-1 blowout over the Tampa Bay Rays. The Mets won’t go down without a fight, however, Quintana’s pitching is too erratic for my liking.

But no matter who wins, I expect the Over on the 9-run total to be hit. The Over is 5-2 in the Mets’ last seven games (9.0 runs per game) and 4-1 in the Yankees’ last five (9.6 per). Four of the last six Mets-Yankees matchups also surpassed their projected total, averaging a combined 11.0 runs along the way.

With an average of 15.0 runs scored in their initial two encounters this season, choosing the Over seems like a safe bet for the Subway Series rivals.

Mets vs. Yankees MLB Prediction: NYY wins

Best Mets vs. Yankees Bet: o9 Total Runs (-115)

Get 50% up to $1,000 on your Mets vs. Yankees MLB predictions today at BetOnline

Best Mets vs Yankees MLB Player Prop (7/23)

Are you hungry for a Mets vs. Yankees player prop? Consider taking Aaron Judge to finish with o1.5 total bases (+117).

5/5 Review Rating

Bonus & Benefits
50% up to $1,000
Bonus Details »

Competitive Odds Pricing
$10 Cash Bonus with code “BNEWS”
Sports, Casino, Poker & Racebook

Bet Now & Claim $1,000 »

Throughout the season, Judge has consistently showcased an MVP-caliber performance, and his recent impressive streak solidifies this claim. Over the span of his last seven games, the six-time MLB All-Star has maintained an outstanding slash line of .409/.606/.864. Along the way, he has accumulated nine hits and three home runs. In these games, Judge has amassed a total of 19 bases, averaging 2.7 per contest, and has finished with the Over five times.

Judge has a solid track record in his recent home games, with the Over being 4-2. Additionally, he has been successful in his last seven matchups against the Mets, where the Over has been 5-2. Given his impressive performance last month at Citi Field, where he accumulated 10 total bases, it is reasonable to anticipate a noteworthy performance from Judge tonight.

Mets vs Yankees MLB Subway Series Predictions, Odds & Best Bets (7/23)